JS Online: Man had 'blueprint' for escort's murder Man had 'blueprint' for escort's murder Attorneys debate whether notes show lack of sanity By JESSICA MCBRIDE jmcbride@journalsentinel.com Last Updated: Dec. 12, 2003 A West Allis man wrote a detailed "blueprint" for the murder and dismemberment of an escort, according to court records and testimony in his homicide trial. The handwritten instructions, which authorities discovered next to the escort's bagged remains in a trash bin behind Keith Michael Addy's apartment, range from "eat one cup of grape nuts," to "walk her directly into room, take off her clothes . . . ." Addy, 27, wrote that he would ask the escort's name and change it to "worm," and that he would call the escort service and say: "I would like a girl that enjoys being tied up, whipped, blindfolded, having hot wax poured on her . . . ." One woman who worked with Beautiful Blondes declined the job because his requests sounded odd, according to previous testimony. But Annamarie Lewandowski agreed to go to Addy's apartment in the 8700 block of W. National Ave. on March 6, where he subsequently carried out his plan, which also indicated that he was going to "quarter" his victim, according to doctors' reports and testimony. The notes, Addy told one doctor, were "a blueprint of the acts. I knew it was supposed to happen to her," records show. Addy allegedly told at least one doctor he believed he was the Messiah. Addy told doctors who examined him as part of his insanity plea that the escort agreed to wear a hood and be burned with candle wax. During the act, he started bludgeoning her over the head with a hammer, reports said. Addy then stabbed Lewandowski, put her body in a bathtub, dismembered her, put her head in a duffel bag, and carried the remains to the trash bin. Addy was convicted earlier this week by Circuit Judge Richard Sankovitz, who is now hearing testimony from four doctors about whether Addy suffered a mental disease or defect at the time of the slaying. If the judge finds that Addy did, and could not control his conduct as a result, Addy would be sent to psychiatric hospital instead of prison. Lawyers are debating whether Addy's notes - and the fact that he tore them up and put them with his victim's remains - are an indication of a mental disorder or of sanity. The prosecution alleges that Addy is making up his insanity after the fact to rationalize the brutal crime. The defense contends Addy was psychotic before and at the time of the slaying and that the notes help prove it. Three of four experts who have submitted reports support Addy's defense, and one does not. Basil Jackson, a Menomonee Falls psychiatrist and attorney, testified Thursday that Addy suffers from a delusional disorder of which the notes, which Jackson called "fragmented" thoughts, are an indication. Jackson called the notes - which also include mentions of wearing a fur hat and turning the television to a certain channel - a "psychotic production." Jackson said that he believed Addy's tearing up the notes was consistent with him trying to resist the forces. But prosecutor Karen Loebel asked the doctor whether that also would be consistent with hiding a crime. Jackson said that was possible. But defense attorney Jerome Buting pointed out that the notes were thrown into a trash bin with other documents that identified Addy, which Jackson said didn't seem consistent with someone trying to hide a crime. But a doctor scheduled to testify today said in his report that Addy's activities were "goal directed and not frenzied" and that Addy said he had cleaned his apartment after the murder to "get away with the crime." That doctor does not support an insanity defense. From the Dec. 12, 2003 editions of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel